
I thought I'd share a post here for anyone whose children are thinking about learning an instrument or even YOU, the adult, are thinking about it. As a music teacher, I have seen the pitfalls over the year of children learning instruments and how parents deal with it and thought I'd put together some tips based on my experience.
1. Go to a concert and watch- is there any instrument you particularly love the sound of? One child fell in love with the sound of an oboe after hearing it in a concert and a girl in my primary school started learning the flute after hearing me play. I heard one of my flute teachers play the flute when I was about 5 and longed to learn the flute. I play a myriad other instruments but the flute remains my true love.
2. If you are worried it might be a short-term fad and don't want to get involved too soon, investigate your child's musical ability by seeing if there are any local music clubs? The music school I went to as a child ran and still runs recorder clubs for all ages and abilities, singing clubs and choirs and since my time, has begun musical clubs for all ages including a musical Kindergarten and music for parents and babies. Here is a link with all the local authority music hubs in the UK. Local churches or nurseries sometimes hold these. Also, sing together, listen to music, encourage going on music sites such as www.nyphilkids.org or the BBC music sections. A love can be built by gentle exposure.
3. You can sometimes go to music shops to try the desired instrument. My sister tried the bassoon at Footes in London as a teen. Some music shops run a hire scheme too. You can also get special interest free loans for buying instruments too.
4. DON'T buy a violin in Argos, Ebay or random locations. They come without being set up (i.e. on a violin, the strings and the bridge are not on the violin so you can't play it, the staff in the shop will have no idea to set it up and I imagine you wouldn't either.) It might seem cheaper, but in the longrun, it really won't be. It's a false economy. Go to a reputable music shop. It's worth it. If there is something that disheartens children learning, it is having an awful instrument. A girl in my orchestra had a terrible violin with pegs that kept slipping so it was out of tune ALL the time. I spent most of the rehearsal retuning it- I hated that violin and so did she. Or ask a teacher for advice. Same with that colourful brand-new Ukele in the charity shop- chances are it will be out of tune and the strings will break.
4. Organisations such as the Wigmore Hall in the London, Spitalfields festival, The London Symphony Orchestra and many of the orchestras (For outside UK and America- look at what your most local profession orchestra is and see what outreach they do) offer workshops and family days you can get involved in. The Southbank centre in London holds children's gamelan lessons and often there will be opportunities to try instruments.
5. Think about your budget. Some instruments work out more expensive than others. The oboe is a great instrument and we need more players of these but the reeds are quite expensive (and the instrument) and they wear out and beginners find it hard to take care of them at first. Bear that in mind. The flute and violin are relatively cheap although when you get good you will need to changes string and bow hair more often.
6. Often parents don't want their children to learn the cello because they think it will be too heavy for their child to carry to school. (I've heard this lots of times) Really? Are you planning to bring it to school every day then? You'll probably only have to bring it on lesson day and I'm sure your child will like to build some muscles. Small cellos are lighter anyway!
7. Can't bear the sound of beginner violin playing? The cello sounds much less squeaky!
8. Instruments WILL sound dreadful at first. But the pain will go away with determination and practice. The instruments that sound the worst are: the violin (strangled neutered cat), the oboe (rancid duck with megaphone), the saxophone (sick cow), cornet (demented magnified wasp combined with klaxon). But they can end up sounding the nicest.
9. When your child (or you) start/s learning, it is not in your/their natural inclination to want to practice. You need to support them in it. Sit with them, make it fun, earn stars. The number of parents I've heard go to the music teacher and say, "I want her to give up, she never practises." Of course she doesn't- she's a child and needs to be helped into good habits! I certainly didn't practice without support. If you're a grown-up- yes, you need to practice if you want to get better. Don't be lazy and say, "Oh I'm just not musical.". Musical learning is a mixture of natural talent and just plain hard work or just needing a bit more hard work.
10. Try to find an opportunity to play with others. One of the greatest joys of music-making is the sociability of it. My teenage friend Marianne's Dad learnt the Bassoon from the age of around 50ish. He did the above and practised and he got good fairly quickly. He then joined a local windband which was wonderful (not least because he played the bassoon and bassoon players are less easy to come by). As a child, I played at church, ran mini-concerts with my friends, played in school orchestras and clubs and the suchlike.

Let me know what you think and about any experience you have had in learning an instrument? Or what you think of these tips. Forgive me if I say anything which you disagree with or sound remotely patronising- not my intention!x
If you need any advice, just ask!
Linking with:
Creative Mondays

Monday Parenting Pin

Brilliant blog posts with Honest Mum blog

Youre' gonna love it Tuesday with Kathe

hi dear,so interesting post..thanks for sharing these tips..
ReplyDeletei love music
I'm glad to hear it! You're welcome!x
DeleteI like this! My goal in life is to always keep learning new things. Since I love music, learning to play musical instruments sounds like fun. Your advice is very helpful.
ReplyDeleteYou are a wise person Ally! xx
DeleteThis is such a helpful and practical post. Are you in a teaching union? If so, you should send a copy of it to your union magazine - it is the sort of thing they'd publish
ReplyDeletexxx
I am but I think they are still sending the magazine to my old house!
DeleteThis is such helpful advice! I would love if my children someday chose to learn an instrument and having this post to look back on will be great. I was that kid that gave up piano at a young age because I didn't practice and wasn't really encouraged to do so. I regret it to this day. I would love to learn to play the guitar and ukulele, as well. I own both instruments and still can't play them. Someday!
ReplyDeleteThanks! I'd love to hear about them learning! PRACTICE my dear!x
DeleteA great post and such valuable advice Kezzie.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, I didn't know you were a music teacher but I knew you love music.
I wanted to learn to play the piano when I was a child but my parents were too poor to pay the sisters at the convent the $5.00 a lesson. All my father could afford way paying $5.00 a week for my solder sister to take typing lessons. It was breaking his heart that he couldn't pay for my lessons but I understood and accepted it.
As I got married and raised my children, I decided to buy a piano for my son and youngest daughter. My son has a beautiful voice and his music teacher suggested that I buy a piano. I did but he never showed any interest. My youngest daughter took piano lessons but wanted to play the oboe and flute. She can play both. I rented an oboe and later I bought her a flute. She took to it like a duck to water but seldom plays now.
I bought myself a Nice Yamaha guitar and was learning to play. My daughter borrowed it and took it to a friend 's apartment. Someone brok in and smashed three guitars including mine. So I never learned to play guitar.
Then in 2001, I bought myself a violin and started to learn to play with a CD and a book. I was making progress then I was diagnosed with breast cancer and has a radical mastectomy and couldn't use my right arm for a long time. My violin is still hanging up on the wall. Now I'm busier than ever so I wonder if ever I'll have tiome to pick up the violin.
Hugs,
JB
OH NO re all the catastrophes with the instruments. You are wonderful person and the music is in your heart x
DeleteOops, I meant my older sister... I love her so...
ReplyDeleteJB
haha.... I stink at anything musical. I'm in awe of those who play well :)
ReplyDeleteBut you are an amazing artist!x
DeleteJust stopping by to say that I'm excited to do a TARDIS Tuesday...when I can find enough time! Gah! :)
ReplyDeleteMiranda
Little Gold Pocket Watch
Yay! Do it!x
DeleteI can make some amazing sounds with my armpit, been playing since I was a teen. A virtuoso by this time :) I did try and take the drums in my teen years but my attention span did not allow more than a few lessons. I have always dreamed about being a famous guitar player but my attention span is even shorter now.
ReplyDeleteI shall not dignify this with an answer! :)
DeleteI'm all about the bass, no treble! I play bass guitar in my church music group. I love the bass, you can make some wonderful sounds, and it provides a foundation for the rest of the group.
ReplyDeleteI am all about treble instruments! We should form a band!
DeleteI used to play the french horn - but was terrible at practising, so didn't really progress very far. I rather wish now I'd learned the sax - I think it's a lovely instrument - but I think my time has passed. The instrument I would like to retrain (probably with a whip and chair!) is my voice. I love singing, and used to have singing lessons, but have lost that too. I can belt out hymns with the best of them, but beyond that...sigh.
ReplyDeleteYou are cool Alison!x
DeleteSuch great tips! Henry has just started trumpet lessons at school. It's nice because the lessons are right after school and they are affordable. And he's taking to it pretty well.
ReplyDeleteOooh,Exciting!!!!x
DeleteThis is great advice Kezzie! I played the flute in school, mostly because my cousin had one to hand down to me - so I really didn't get to make the choice. Now mind you, I ended up loving it, but I wish I had taken the time to really think about it. I am going to save this post and keep these things in mind when Ollie is old enough to try out an instrument!
ReplyDeleteYay Ollie musician! Hururah for the flute!
DeleteGreat tips - I completely agree with you. The only problem my parents faced was the fact that I was determined to be a harpist!! Jx
ReplyDeleteExpensive tastes eh!
DeleteI loved my clarinet but I missed playing with people when I left school.
ReplyDeleteLizzie Dripping
Ooh, cool you play the Clarinet! Is there any band nearby where you live?x
DeleteThe son is currently in school band with a wonderful instructor but the daughter wants piano lessons and I'm loath to grant her request when her attention span measures similarly to that of a flea's. Will keep your advice in mind when she finally shows sincere determination.
ReplyDeleteMaybe wait till she's a bit older like you say. There's no harm in it!x
DeleteGreat tips Kezzie, I wish I had learned to play some kind of music myself!! love to hear the saxophone on films :) thanks for linking up to Creative Mondays..
ReplyDeleteHi Kezzie, sorry it took me so long to stop by hehe the kids wanted some tea, featuring this post too later at Creative Mondays too :)
DeleteThank you for linking your post with the #pinitparty
ReplyDeleteLove this, Oliver my eldest wants to start piano lessons soon, we got him a keyboard first and will build up (save) for a piano if he shows he likes it when he starts. He also quite likes the recorder (forgot how loud that thing is from when I was at school-the lovely thing is he's using my old one)! Thanks for linking up to #brilliantblogposts
ReplyDeleteGreat post.
ReplyDelete4) This is so very true. One thing I try to persuade my learners' parents of is that the instrument they buy may well be with them for the rest of their lives. So it's better to get the right instrument than a cheap instrument. Fortunately, we have a couple of people in the band who work, or have worked, in music shops, so I generally direct the parents to go ask them for advice!
8) Add the bagpipes to the list of instruments that sound terrible when you start out. And there's no volume control...
9) Oddly, I haven't tended to have this problem. Instead, my big problem is that learners will want to rush on to more complex tunes before they're ready and/or play tunes way too fast and get into all sorts of bad habits. You don't want to discourage them, but it's frustrating when you can see them making exactly the same mistakes as the learners you taught five years ago...
Thank you for recommending our Family Concerts :-) We've got one coming up this Sunday, 8 Feb (Spanish-themed) and another on 26 April, based on Anna Kemp's book Dogs Don't Do Ballet – just in case anyone fancies joining. http://www.lso.co.uk/events-for-families
ReplyDelete