Monday, April 21, 2014

The eternal mystery of Smarties

Image taken from here
As Lent is now over, I am free to eat chocolate and crisps to my heart's content again. My sister bought me a box of Smarties (For our lovely international readers who may have not tried Smarties- they are essentially a sort of M&M's- bigger and flatter, without a letter on top- they used to come in tubes which could be turned into panpipes if you blew across the top) for my birthday in February which I haven't been able to eat.  The box is just like the ones they used to (and probably still do) sell at our local theatre when I was a child/teen.  Oh, the joy of going to the glass fronted, wooden-paneled booth at our local theatre to choose which box of sweets- would it be the jelly babies- most delicious but alas, few given and eaten quickly; Smarties- lots of them but they always melted and became shiny and sticky; Fruit gums- lasted for AGES but really annoying as you had to suck them and couldn't chew if you got frustrated; Fruit pastilles- the best of all worlds- lots of them, could be chewed or sucked and didn't melt: Still, I didn't always choose them.

BUT, I digress! Back to the main point.  As I opened this nostalgic box of Smarties, the age old eponymous question occurred to me: WHY do only the orange Smarties have a distinctive taste?  They were always my favourite as they tasted of orange (and I've just checked- they STILL do).  Why were all the other Smarties just that generic chocolate, Smartie flavour?  There was a brief spate of time in my life when I believed that the (at the time) newly-introduced blue ones had their own flavour.  Do you remember that they replaced the light brown variety?  When I was very young, there used to be a light brown AND a dark brown variety.   There was a time when they introduced the white Smartie- white chocolate (but still no special flavour).

Nowadays, the colourings are made from (in the words of the Maker) "from Nature's colourful palette"
(For the sake of transparency, they come from the following: Red= hibiscus fruit; purple= red cabbage; yellow= lemon;  green= Spirulina; pink= radish; brown= black carrot)
and the colours are less lurid than their '80's counterparts, but the mystery remains, the orange ones still taste of orange (there's orange oil in the ingredients list), but ALL the others are equal.

WHY did Nestle only choose to flavour the orange ones?????


It seems only Smarties have the answer....

15 comments:

  1. Smarties are a different sort of candy here...Now I want to try these ones!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is one of life's mysteries. I once had a protracted conversation with a colleague who insisted the flavours, other than orange, were all equal and that the dark brown one didn't have a slight bitterness to it. I never knew what the other colours or flavourings were but the idea of cabbage seems so at odds with a choccie treat. Still in the interests of research you understand I'll need to get myself a bag.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I miss the old blue smarties. I also remember ltd edition ones with pictures on...and also special white chocolate ones x

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. YES!! Those crazy alien ones? And the glow in the dark lids?

      Delete
  4. I miss the letter on the lid - why did they stop doing that?

    ReplyDelete
  5. I miss the proper blue ones, but understand why they got rid of them; they used to make me incredibly hyperactive. I still remember when Smarties did special football-stripe themed tubes, and (whilst staying with my Nan) I got an ENTIRE TUBE of only blue Smarties. I was bouncing off the walls. My poor Nan.... xxx

    ReplyDelete
  6. I haven't had any for years - I used to love the letter on the lid. x

    ReplyDelete
  7. A white chocolate one? That passed me by!
    Lisa x

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh I forgot about the white ones! They made blue ones later on in childhood and apparently they made kids hyper!! I LOVE orange too, not so interested in the rest with no taste. My Grandad used to bring us smarties and a milky way (mini ones) each visit. Some of my cousins called him 'Chocolate Grandad' to distinguish between their other Grandad (I only ever had one). At his funeral my Auntie got us all Smarties and Milky Ways-it was the one moment I teared up.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I remember there was a big fuss about 20 years ago when the public found out the red coloring came from beetles! I think it was Smarties, and maybe other candies with red coloring. Hibiscus sounds much better!

    ReplyDelete
  10. It is all psychological. The fact the orange ones tastes different means something...like Richard Dreyfuss is Close Encounters of the 3rd Kind. Oh, that reference is too old for the room perhaps? Letting it stand :)

    And the fact I think it is the letters that give M & M's all their taste should in no way cast doubt on my diagnosis :)P

    ReplyDelete
  11. I miss the letter on the lid too.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I had forgotten about the boxes of smarties! Sarah x

    ReplyDelete
  13. I haven't had smarties for a long time but I've noticed the orange flavour thing too!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Yeah, I'm pretty sure it's psychological. Here's a question: do they still taste different if you eat them blind-folded?

    ReplyDelete

Greetings! Welcome to the maaaaaadness! I am so glad you came to visit and leave me a pretty comment!! Would you like tea and cakes? The books are over on the shelf! I have sofas a-plenty so leave us a friendly comment and I'll pretty much guarantee I'll come a-visiting to you at some point soon!! This blog-post will self-destruct in 2 minutes. Go, type, type, type!!!!! (and put a hat on!)