In my continuing journey to try and eliminate as much single-use plastic as I can from my life, I have been addressing the bathroom cabinet and one of the throwaway culprits which is harder to recycle is Deodorant.
Deodorant and I have had a long and difficult relationship. My body seems to 'get used' to particular deodorants and then fail. Over the last 15 years, I have investigated a large variety of natural deodorants because of the fears of Aluminium having a link to Breast-cancer but have returned to conventional ones. All of the above come in solid plastic which, until recently, most recycling authorities that I lived under, didn't accept. I find it scary to think about all the deodorant tubes that I am responsible for which are in landfill somewhere.
As a consequence, I had seen various cardboard-wrapped deodorants on Instagram #Plasticfree posts and wanted to give them a go.
It was therefore, a glad moment back in December last year, when I discovered our most local Zero-waste room, The Refill Room, stocked different cardboard deodorants. I bought CBC one to go with his Christmas presents (along with a bamboo pot scraper and an olive wood soap dish- romance is alive in our house!) and purchased myself one.
As you can see from the picture below, I am showing you what the products look like used! It's all glamour here.
I've reviewed the two I have used and CBC will review his one (his is the smallest one).
For the record- the cost of these IS more than your average deodorant. If you are on a budget, it is a lot.. However, since I have used natural deodorants over the years, the price is comparable to ones I have purchased and since I don't use makeup really or vast amounts of products, for me, it is worth spending that bit more.
CBC's words:
The product itself was a good deodorant. It was effect, had a nice smell and an organic flavour to it. Being a 'dry' product meant that sometimes, it was less comfortable to use than a liquid roll on; you had to warm it up or soften it in your armpit before it came off effectively and then when you took it away, it resulted in hairs being left behind. The cardboard container is robust enough for a short use but if you are taking it places or using it lots, it doesn't compare to your traditional deodorant. All-in-all, these are small inconveniences to pay for an effective deodorant product which uses no plastic and can be composted or recycled.
The details:
- 100% Natural ingredients
- Plastic free – packaging is biodegradable and recyclable
- Cruelty free
- Ethically and sustainably sourced ingredients
- NO Palm Oil, Aluminium or Parabens
- Handmade in Wales
Ingredients:
Butyrospermum Parkii** (Shea Butter)
Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil**
Theobroma Cacao (Cocoa Butter)
Cera Alba (Beeswax)
Arrowroot
Bicarbonate of Soda**
Grapefruit Oil
Lemon Oil
Peppermint Oil
Sweet Orange Oil
Linalool*, Limonene*, Citral*
**Organic Ingredient
*Naturally occurring components in essential oils.
I was worried about my problem that often natural deodorant wasn't always effective on me as it isn't an Anti-perspirant- you will still sweat but wanted to give this a go. It is lovely to use. It ACTUALLY works on me and I don't smell. It feels really good and smells really natural. Unlike CBC, with less hairy arm, it goes on smoothly and feels nice- no irritation. One thing is I worry I use too much of it in one go. Sometimes it ends up around the rim of the tube so I try to wipe it onto my armpits with the edge. Pushing up the deodorant to get more is as simple as shoving a finger up the bottom but occasionally, I pushed on the bottom too much -it's kind of hard to get it back in and I've taken to carefully puttting the lid on, but not pushing it right down- not so easy if travelling. It seemed to last for quite a while- I can't remember how long it lasted but seemed to go on for a while. However, as I got towards the end, because this tube is longer than CBC's, I couldn't reach up the tube anymore to push it up. I used my bamboo toothbrush end to do this which was fine but make sure you push it in the middle- it went wonky when I didn't. At the end, it is hard to know how to use it as the last bit of deodorant is sort of balanced on a cardboard disk- I took the disk attached to the bit of deodorant out of the tube and rubbed it on my armpits which worked fine and just put it back on top with the lid balanced on top. The packaging did get a bit 'shea-buttery' as you can probably see from the pictures and did get a bit knackered with travelling but it stood the test and was not a problem. Don't leave it standing in the sun though!! I'd definitely use this again if they hadn't stopped stocking it in the refill room.
 |
I've added some close-up shots of the product close towards its end to see how it holds up in terms of appearance etc. |
The details:
ECO CREDENTIALS
- Plastic free. Your Nature reduce the amount of waste going to landfill with completely zero waste packaging.
- 100% Natural - contains no aluminium, parabens or carcinogens
- 100% Vegan and Cruelty Free
- Palm Oil Free
- Recyclable and/or compostable packaging
- Handcrafted in the UK
INGREDIENTS
Coconut Oil (Cocos nucifera) *
Arrowroot Powder (Maranta arundinacea) *
Sodium Bicarbonate,
Mango Butter (Mangifera indica)
Shea Butter (Butyrospermum Parkii) *
Candelilla Wax (Candelilla cera)
Vitamin E (Tocopherols)
Lavender Essential Oil (Lavandula angustifolia)
Bergamot Essential Oil (Citrus Bergamia)
Citral ** Geraniol ** Linalool ** Citronellol ** Limonene **
* Organic
** Naturally occurring potential allergens
I bought this one as a substitute since the previous one was not being stocked again. This tube size is more sensible and seems quite robust. It survived being away for 3 weeks in a wash bag.
It rolls on really easily and feels really pleasant on the armpits. The smell is attractive. It worked on most days that I used it although on a hot day in Siena, I felt like ONE of my armpits was smelly and the other wasn't! What is that about? It's easy to push the end of the tube up and I felt like I had more control over the amount I pushed up compared to my other one or maybe I was less gung-ho with this one. It seems to last well though again, some of it ends up around the side of the rim so again, I am wiping off the edge onto my armpit so as not to waste it. I've not got to the end yet so I will let you know if there are any issues with that but all in all, I am very pleased with this product. I like the Shea butter- it is a lovely deodorant base and I feel it works for me and feels healthy for my skin. I will be buying this again (in fact, I have a second tube lined up!)
The details:
No aluminium, parabens or carcinogens
Allows your skin to breath and perspire naturally
Will not block your sweat glands and will allow your body to remove toxins as nature intended
Totally cruelty free
Supports healthy marine life
Biodegradable, Recyclable packaging, no plastic
Suitable for men, women and teens
Vegan Friendly
Made in the Isle of Wight.
Ingredients:
Certified organic coconut oil, arrowroot powder, certified organic shea butter, sodium bicarbonate, sunflower wax, Jasmine Absolute, Rose Absolute, Ylang Ylang Oil
*Ingredients naturally occurring in Essential Oils
All in all, this is a swap I definitely want to stick with. I like the products hugely and think the extra expense is worth it for a deodorant that works, that isn't full of harmful chemicals and that I know can be disposed of super easily.
What do you think? Would you try them?
xx